Blog

Covid-19 and Basic Income for the Poor of India? by Dr. Michael Hopkins FRSA

Desperate poor of India migrating out of Delhi to seek food, Al Jazeera, Mar 30 2020

Many have vouched for the need to provide a basic income for all if we are to solve many problems of hardship around the world.  In India shocking images, as shown in the above photo, have emerged of lakhs of migrant workers desperately walking even hundreds of kilometres to their villages where they have an increased hope of receiving enough food. All started from Narendra Modi’s sudden decision to effect a nationwide lockdown as of March 22. There is no doubt that such drastic measures will help to stop the spread of such an infectious virus as Covid-19. Even harder for Indians, being such warm and sociable people, is the need for social distancing to keep the disease at bay.But as measures to contain it, unfold, we are witnessing a humanitarian and economic crisis of unprecedented proportions[1].

Hardship especially for very poor people, quickly follows.  The measures announced by the government so far have really hit hard markets, transport, tourism, basic services as well as social gatherings.  These measures are crucial to stop the virus spreading but also lead to fewer means for the poor to exercise small and micro business activities, and hence a loss of their meagre incomes.  Poor people are poor not because they are lazy.  Far from it.  The poor generally work long hours for tiny rewards.  They must not be punished for that and the police beating people at random for not observing curfews must be stopped.  Poor people must be helped not punished.

Around the world some propose radical changes to the public sector, as it is noted that the virus has led to increased debt and potential bankruptcy.  “They will not be saved by tax breaks and more credit; they need people to be able and willing to buy their goods,” says Guy Standing in https://www.idler.co.uk/article/why-coronavirus-must-lead-to-a-basic-income-for-all/].  Standing further argues strongly in favour of a basic income for everyone. I have analysed elsewhere the pros and cons of basic income [see https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/basic-income-bi-corporate-social-responsibility-csris-hopkins/ ], but there is no doubt that giving poor people extra financial resources will bounce back immediately into increased consumption, of which most will go to the private sector.  Better, much better, than merely eliminating corporate tax breaks to the tune of one trillion dollars as done in the USA.  The result was a boom in the stock market as companies bought their own shares further enriching the already rich.  More recently, the USA has decided to inject a further 2 billion dollars and this time with opposition support.

In India, the Central government has announced a Rs. 1.7 trillion package ($US126bn) aimed at alleviation of the impact of the lockdown on the poor over the next three months.  In addition some  states have announced additional measures and relief packages varying in nature and scale. But these are very small compared to the huge size of India with a total GDP of $US2.6 trillion in 2017.

The ISLE letter noted that the announcement of transferring Rs. 500 per month to each JDY woman account holder was grossly insufficient. They insisted that the “Centre and States together should try and ensure a minimum transfer over the next three months of at least Rs 6000 per month with a major part borne by the Central Government.” However for poor people even $10 per month (roughly Rs.1000) for each family member would help both them and their local economy. A quick calculation shows that for the estimated 5.5% of the population (78 million) who are desperately poor the total cost of Rs1000 per month for 3 months (the estimated time the crisis will last) would total Rs234billion or $US17.3billion.  Compared to the Rs1.7 trillion cited above, that sum would be eminently manageable.

Then, as ISLE noted, “special effort has to be made to make assistance to be provided on a non-discriminatory basis”.  But delivery could be a problem since not all poor households, have bank accounts, and proper mechanisms need to be evolved on how cash assistance be designed for them. Further, non-discrimination means that special efforts must be made for landless households/individuals who have few methods by which they might be identified.  In Kenya, just about everyone who is poor has a mobile phone that can accept mobile money – known as MPESA.  Kenya is poorer than India, but not by much.

Some have suggested, as occurs in refugee camps, that we distribute food and medical supplies to the poor. This could be done with a combination of institutions such as the Red Cross, the World Bank, international aid bodies, service organisation such as Rotary, the private sector (both Rotary and the private sector are already active in this regard) and government.  All well and good, and this should be further encouraged.  But regular cash brings immediate benefits, and brings the additional benefit of stimulating the local economy for those poor souls who are really stuck right now.

Basic income benefits would be immediate.  Poor people would immediately spend on local services and food, thereby creating a decentralised and large effective demand for the slum economies.  Yes, some may be used for criminal or socially abusive activities.  That cannot be avoided unfortunately, although cash transfers would help prevent criminality, providing a signal that the government really cares. Cash is king, and most of the money will go through useful outlets and help the poor significantly.

[1] Drawn from a letter to Modi by a large number of academics from the Indian Society of Labour Economics (ISLE) in New Delhi, March 2020.

143 Comments

  1. best cbd oil

    These are genuinely impressive ideas in on the topic of blogging.
    You have touched some good things here. Any way keep up wrinting.

  2. JanePoown

    [url=https://diflucanf.com/]diflucan 150 mg prescription[/url]

  3. EvaPoown

    [url=http://albenzamed.com/]albenza price[/url]

  4. MarkPoown

    [url=https://paxil24.com/]generic paxil cr[/url] [url=https://lasixsale.com/]best over the counter lasix[/url]

  5. WimPoown

    [url=http://bectrim.com/]bactrim medication[/url]

  6. ปั้มไลค์

    Like!! Really appreciate you sharing this blog post.Really thank you! Keep writing.

  7. กรองหน้ากากอนามัย

    I like the valuable information you provide in your articles.

  8. LisaPoown

    [url=https://cymbaltarx.com/]cymbalta generic[/url]

  9. TeoPoown

    [url=https://baclofenonline.com/]baclofen 10mg tablets[/url]

  10. TedPoown

    [url=https://iventolin.com/]ventolin for sale[/url] [url=https://advairdisk.com/]how to buy advair cheap[/url] [url=https://indocinrx.com/]indocin tablets[/url]

  11. AmyPoown

    [url=https://sildenafilv.com/]buy sildenafil[/url]

  12. KiaPoown

    [url=http://cymbaltarx.com/]generic for cymbalta[/url]

  13. Sildenafil 100 mg tablet coupon

    Thanks so much for the post.Really thank you! Keep writing.sildenafil 100 mg tablet coupon

  14. LisaPoown

    [url=https://baclofenonline.com/]baclofen cost 10mg[/url]

  15. LisaPoown

    [url=https://diclofenacg.com/]diclofenac brand name drug[/url]

  16. YonPoown

    [url=https://toradolrx.com/]buy toradol[/url] [url=https://amoxicillinlab.com/]amoxicillin 875 mg pill[/url]

  17. Social Media Marketing

    I have been examinating out some of your articles and it’s clever stuff. I will definitely bookmark your blog.

  18. TeoPoown

    [url=https://lasixwtp.com/]lasix online no prescription[/url]

  19. ZakPoown

    [url=https://anafranilmed.com/]anafranil 25 mg[/url] [url=https://indocinrx.com/]indocin generic[/url] [url=https://amoxicillinlab.com/]amoxicillin capsule 500mg price[/url]

  20. AmyPoown

    [url=https://benicar24.com/]benicar hct[/url]

  21. เบอร์สวยมงคล

    Hi there, after reading this amazing paragraph i am as well delighted to share my knowledge here with friends.

  22. LisaPoown

    [url=https://ciproflxn.com/]ciprofloxacin 500mg[/url]

  23. LisaPoown

    [url=https://clonidinemed.com/]buy clonidine[/url]

  24. AmyPoown

    [url=https://clonidinemed.com/]clonidine hcl 0.3 mg[/url]

  25. Generic cialis

    Thanks a lot for the article post.Much thanks again. Fantastic.generic cialis

  26. AmyPoown

    [url=https://arimidex.us.org/]arimidex[/url]

  27. LisaPoown

    [url=https://arimidex.us.org/]buy arimidex[/url]

  28. KiaPoown

    [url=http://amoxicillintz.com/]can i buy amoxicillin over the counter[/url]

  29. LisaPoown

    [url=https://inderal.us.com/]buy inderal[/url]

  30. http://zavzdrav.shoppy.pl/

    Ucuz Kapıda Ödeme Kitap 2016 En Iyi Roman Kitapları

    My homepage – book epub (http://zavzdrav.shoppy.pl/)

  31. AmyPoown

    [url=https://kamagra360.com/]discount kamagra[/url]

  32. TeoPoown

    [url=https://metforminglc.com/]metformin 500mg[/url]

  33. SMS

    Your site is very helpful. Many thanks for sharing!

  34. LisaPoown

    [url=https://erythromycin24.com/]erythromycin 400 mg tablets[/url]

  35. http://zolseabo.shoppy.pl/

    En Çok Okunan Kitaplar Kitap Siparis Almanya

    My homepage: library (http://zolseabo.shoppy.pl/)

  36. KiaPoown

    [url=http://baclofenp.com/]baclofen 4097[/url]

  37. bog

    Yeni Roman Kitapları Güncel Kitaplar 2015

    Look at my website; bog

  38. pdf book

    D&R Satın Alma Yeni Kitaplar 2016

    Also visit my website … pdf book

  39. http://strebby.shoppy.pl

    Talking To Strangers Queen Of Cuba Charles Dickens Books For
    Beginners

    Take a look at my webpage :: bog (http://strebby.shoppy.pl)

  40. AmyPoown

    [url=https://yasminmed.com/]generic yasmin[/url]

  41. TeoPoown

    [url=https://arimidex.us.org/]buy arimidex[/url]

  42. MarkPoown

    [url=https://baclofenp.com/]can you buy baclofen over the counter us[/url] [url=https://clonidinemed.com/]buy clonidine[/url]

  43. nicereview.trustlike.tw1.ru

    10th New Book Maths Guide Tamil Medium The Forever War Chapter 1 Summary

    Also visit my web blog: ebook (nicereview.trustlike.tw1.ru)

  44. WimPoown

    [url=http://baclofenp.com/]baclofen medication[/url]

  45. JerrySnips

    Знаете ли вы?
    Старейший депутат Палаты представителей проработал в Конгрессе США почти до 92 лет.
    Самцы косатки, обитающие в Британской Колумбии, всю жизнь живут с мамой.
    Альбом «Битлз», признанный одним из величайших в истории музыки, ругали за искусственность и «перепродюсированность».
    Возможно, что американцы уже в 1872 году вмешались в канадские выборы.
    Подруга и последовательница Льва Толстого уже в детстве ходила босиком и отвергала нарядную одежду.

    [url=http://arbeca.net/]http://www.arbeca.net/[/url]

  46. LisaPoown

    [url=https://colchicinetab.com/]buy colchicine online canada[/url]

  47. AmyPoown

    [url=https://buypropecia247.us.org/]finasteride online bonus[/url]

  48. book epub

    Analytical Chemistry Worksheet Nonhuman Voices In Anglo-Saxon Literature And Material Culture

    Look at my site … book epub

  49. TeoPoown

    [url=https://lxapro.com/]lexapro[/url]

  50. ioplux.shoppy.pl

    Urantia Daily The Secret History Of Jesuits Pdf

    Look into my homepage – pdf book – ioplux.shoppy.pl,

  51. AmyPoown

    [url=https://phenergan365.com/]phenergan price[/url]

  52. Earn Money Online

    Excellent read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing some research on that. And he just bought me lunch because I found it for him smile So let me rephrase that: Thanks for lunch!

  53. LisaPoown

    [url=https://tretinoin365.com/]tretinoin 0.025[/url]

  54. Affiliate Marketing

    I have been reading out a few of your articles and it’s pretty clever stuff. I will make sure to bookmark your blog.

  55. http://plohed.shoppy.pl/

    Rbse 6th Class Science Book pdf, http://plohed.shoppy.pl/, Download
    The Great Believers New York Times

  56. KiaPoown

    [url=http://tadallafil.com/]india tadalafil[/url]

  57. booreaderz.blogspot.com

    Best Vampire Novels 2018 Ottessa Moshfegh Movie

    My web site … bog – booreaderz.blogspot.com

  58. TeoPoown

    [url=https://bupropionx.com/]bupropion 857[/url]

  59. crexbooks.blogspot.com

    Bill Nye Saves The World Cringe Vocational Courses Uk
    List

    Here is my blog: library (crexbooks.blogspot.com)

  60. ZakPoown

    [url=https://isotretinoin24.com/]accutane buy[/url] [url=https://tadallafil.com/]tadalafil[/url]

  61. stremmys.shoppy.pl

    Little Black Book Pastry Scientific Method 5 Basic Steps

    Also visit my web page :: book epub, stremmys.shoppy.pl,

  62. AmyPoown

    [url=https://albuterolmd.com/]0.63 mg albuterol[/url]

  63. KiaPoown

    [url=http://isotretinoin24.com/]buy accutane[/url]

  64. AmyPoown

    [url=https://ivermectin.us.org/]ivermectin[/url]

  65. LisaPoown

    [url=https://nexium.us.org/]nexium 7 tablets[/url]

  66. pdf

    Vocational School Nj Pseb.Ac.In 12th Result 2018 Vocational

    Feel free to visit my site … pdf

  67. TeoPoown

    [url=https://proscar.us.com/]can i buy proscar over the counter[/url]

  68. books

    Great Lakes Science Center Bodies The Undoing Project Kirkus

    Here is my page books

  69. pdf book

    Emotional Intelligence Book In Gujarati Howard Stern Book Signing Los Angeles

    Also visit my web page :: pdf book

  70. JerrySnips

    Знаете ли вы?
    Новый вид пауков-скакунов был назван по имени писателя в честь юбилея его самой известной книги о гусенице.
    Американская энциклопедия включила в себя десятки статей о вымышленных людях, якобы связанных с Латинской Америкой.
    Биограф русского художника романтизировала историю его французской прародительницы вслед за Герценом.
    Старейший депутат Палаты представителей проработал в Конгрессе США почти до 92 лет.
    Двое капитанов первого кругосветного плавания были казнены, следующего высадили на необитаемый остров.

    [url=http://arbeca.net/]http://arbeca.net[/url]

  71. baskedd.shoppy.pl

    Skippyjon Jones Directed Drawing Cbse School In Ahmedabad Near Me

    Also visit my blog post … pdf book (baskedd.shoppy.pl)

  72. pdf book

    Best Fiction Books Ever Made 7 College Admission Website

    Check out my web site; pdf book

  73. cerdaer.shoppy.pl

    Sci Journal List Computer Science Vince Flynn Death Notice

    Also visit my homepage :: best books (cerdaer.shoppy.pl)

  74. Pedro Corbridge

    I just want to say I’m new to weblog and absolutely loved this blog site. More than likely I’m want to bookmark your website . You really have excellent articles. Regards for sharing your web page.

  75. pdf

    Thermodynamics Physics Syllabus Chicken Soup For The
    Soul Font

    Feel free to visit my blog … pdf

  76. CBD Gummies

    This is a excellent blog, would you be involved in doing an interview about just how you designed it? If so e-mail me!

  77. Son

    Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I have truly enjoyed browsing your blog posts. After all I’ll be subscribing to your rss feed and I hope you write again very soon!

  78. CBD for sale

    Glad to be one of the visitors on this awe inspiring web site : D.

  79. Simona Caler

    My brother suggested I might like this web site. He was totally right. This post actually made my day. You can not imagine just how much time I had spent for this information! Thanks!

  80. bog

    Secondary Schools Near Redhill Define Chemical Reservoir Geology

    Visit my site; bog

  81. pure cbd

    I like this blog so much, saved to my bookmarks .

  82. sgeukko.shoppy.pl

    New York Times Best Sellers Untamed Skippyjon Jones Lesson Plans

    my web page; book epub, sgeukko.shoppy.pl,

  83. John Deere Diagnostic and Test Manuals

    Hi! Aw, this was a really nice post. In idea I would like to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and actual effort to make a very good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and by no means seem to get something done.

  84. John Deere Repair Manuals

    Hey, you used to write magnificent, but the last several posts have been kinda boringЎK I miss your super writings. Past several posts are just a little out of track! come on!

  85. Albuquerque

    Hello, I think your website might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your website in Safari, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, great blog!

  86. http://wphpvww.shoppy.pl/

    Novel12 Discovery Of Witches Bookz

    Here is my blog … pdf book (http://wphpvww.shoppy.pl/)

  87. scztxr.shoppy.pl

    Wet Deposition Chemistry Graphic Novel Illustration Styles

    Check out my web site :: library (scztxr.shoppy.pl)

  88. TedPoown

    [url=https://ciprofloxacin24.com/]ciprofloxacin 250mg[/url] [url=https://chloroquine.us.com/]aralen india[/url] [url=https://kamagratb.com/]kamagra online[/url]

  89. ebook

    Parsons School Of Design Virtual Tour Ramaiah Medical College
    Quora

    Here is my blog post … ebook

  90. pdf

    Sapiens Careers Ms University Result 2019 November

    My web-site – pdf

  91. pdf

    Doki Doki Literature Club Websites Unlimited Power Corp

    Here is my web blog … pdf

  92. qwqevua.shoppy.pl

    Public School Calendar Portland Or Traditional Literature Children’S Lit

    My web page; ebook (qwqevua.shoppy.pl)

  93. TeoPoown

    [url=https://baclofen24.com/]buy baclofen[/url]

  94. jspelu.shoppy.pl

    National Science Learning Centre York Liane Moriarty Books Kmart

    My blog post: bog – jspelu.shoppy.pl,

  95. ebook

    Journal Of Agricultural Science And Technology Tarbiat Modares University World Education Services Wikipedia

    Stop by my web blog; ebook

  96. WimPoown

    [url=http://wellbutrinbupropion.com/]buy bupropion[/url]

  97. WimPoown

    [url=http://priligytab.com/]generic priligy[/url]

  98. CBD Cream

    Exceptional entry! I found it very interesting. I’ll check back later to see if more posts are added.

  99. YonPoown

    [url=https://atorvastatin.us.com/]cost of lipitor[/url] [url=https://priligytab.com/]where can i buy priligy[/url] [url=https://amoxicillinz.com/]250 amoxicillin[/url]

  100. AshPoown

    [url=http://tadalafilsale.com/]buy tadalafil[/url] [url=http://kamagratb.com/]kamagra buy[/url] [url=http://cymbaltaduloxetine.com/]duloxetine cymbalta[/url]

  101. TedPoown

    [url=https://erythromycinz.com/]erythromycin gel australia[/url] [url=https://sildenafil36.com/]sildenafil 100mg[/url] [url=https://amoxicillinz.com/]amoxicillin 22 mg[/url]

  102. 퍼스트카지노

    Exactly what is the best Canon Powershot electronic (duh) camera? I are interested for mostly casual pictures (christmas, birthdays, family reunions that almost stuff). And occasionally a group of cool artistic photos. Im told than a 6-7 mm lens may be the best Other than in which, what else is very good???

  103. 온라인카지노

    Wow! After alll I got a webpage from where I can actually obtain valuable information concerning my study and knowledge.

  104. 카지노사이트

    Fantastic post.Much thanks again. Really Cool.

  105. Google

    I blog quite often and I truly appreciate your information. Your article has truly peaked my interest. I will bookmark your website and keep checking for new details about once per week. I subscribed to your RSS feed as well.

  106. https://worldemojiday2021.blogspot.com

    Everything I Never Told You Quotes Chapter 1 Subjective Poetry And Its
    Different Forms

    My web site … best books (https://worldemojiday2021.blogspot.com)

  107. WimPoown

    [url=http://vermox.us.org/]vermox 100mg tablets[/url]

  108. ps4backbuttonattachment.blogspot.com

    Precipitation Chemistry Bbc Bitesize The Red Queen Ebook

    my webpage … best books – ps4backbuttonattachment.blogspot.com,

  109. Affiliate Marketing

    Rattling wonderful info can be found on web site.

  110. WimPoown

    [url=http://avodart24.com/]avodart 0.5 mg price[/url]

  111. sissy phone chat line

    I’m gone to tell my little brother, that he should also go to see this blog on regular basis to take updated from newest reports.

  112. AshPoown

    [url=http://tretinoin365.com/]order tretinoin 0.05[/url] [url=http://triamterenebenzathiazide.com/]triamterene tablet[/url]

  113. books

    Children’S Books In Xhosa Sudha Murthy Books Vk

  114. bog

    The Black Company Online Free The Giving Tree Font

    Feel free to visit my web-site … bog

  115. gamestoplayonzoom.blogspot.com

    Oliver Jeffers Pdf Romantic Period English Literature Pdf

    Also visit my web site … library – gamestoplayonzoom.blogspot.com,

  116. book epub

    Who Goes There Von John W. Campbell Jr Macbeth Context Gcse Notes

    my web site – book epub

  117. http://stocked.atwebpages.com/readuj4f.html

    Seventeenth Church Of Christ Scientist Chicago Foreign Scientist And Their Works

    Visit my homepage; Special School Kew (http://stocked.atwebpages.com/readuj4f.html)

  118. ebooksa-store.company.site

    Home Science Tools Build A Solar Oven Romantic Urdu Poetry Books
    Pdf

    my web site; ebook; ebooksa-store.company.site,

  119. treapsterre.onlinewebshop.net

    Grade 6 Science Volcano Feminism And Feminist Literary Criticism Definition

    Here is my page – Inspirational Books Must Read (treapsterre.onlinewebshop.net)

  120. Gina

    I’m not that much of a internet reader to be honest but your blogs really nice, keep it up! I’ll go ahead and bookmark your website to come back in the future. Cheers

  121. WimPoown

    [url=http://elimitepermethrin.com/]buy elimite online[/url]

  122. Clinton Cardono

    Great looking web site. Assume you did a lot of your own html coding.

  123. WimPoown

    [url=http://anafranilmed.com/]anafranil australia[/url]

  124. AshPoown

    [url=http://zofranondansetron.com/]buy zofran online no prescription[/url] [url=http://erythromycinlab.com/]erythromycin online purchase[/url]

  125. LisaPoown

    [url=https://triamterenebenzathiazide.com/]triamterene-hctz 75-50 mg[/url]

  126. BooPoown

    [url=http://lasixwtp.com/]order lasix[/url] [url=http://malegra.us.org/]malegra[/url]

  127. UgoPoown

    [url=http://cytotec100.com/]cytotec australia[/url] [url=http://phenergan125.com/]phenergan cream[/url]

  128. WimPoown

    [url=http://ampicillin24.com/]purchase ampicillin[/url]

  129. adreamoftrains website host

    It’s a shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d definitely donate to this
    fantastic blog! I guess for now i’ll settle for
    bookmarking and adding your RSS feed to
    my Google account. I look forward to fresh updates and will share this blog
    with my Facebook group. Talk soon! adreamoftrains website host

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.